Photo: Courtesy of the Argyle Theater (social media) · Editorial use with venue permission
Argyle Theater Cabaret — Broadway in Babylon
Six Broadway and Off-Broadway performers in an intimate cabaret format at the Argyle. 90 minutes, no intermission, table seating with a two-drink minimum. The performers rotate week to week — Argyle posts the lineup the Monday before. This is the most professional intimate-venue cabaret on the South Shore.
The Argyle’s Sunday cabaret nights bring touring Broadway and Off-Broadway performers to Babylon Village. Six artists, 90 minutes, no intermission — fast-paced, intimate, the kind of show that makes you remember why live performance matters.
Date-night logistics:
- Front-balcony two-tops are the move — book the moment they release
- Dinner first at Mara’s (Italian, 3-min walk) or Argyle Grill (also walkable)
- Two-drink minimum at the cabaret
- Out by 9:15 — plenty of time for a nightcap at Argyle Grill after
This Long Island may earn a small commission when you buy tickets through our links. It never affects what we cover or recommend.
Other Arts events
Editor's Pick Bay Street Theater — Summer Mainstage Opening Night
Sag Harbor's beloved 299-seat regional theater opens its 2026 summer mainstage season. Premiere-night audience, celebrity sightings, real theatrical ambition. Plan dinner at Tutto Il Giorno or American Hotel — both walkable, both reserve weeks ahead in July.
- When
- Where
- Bay Street Theater, Sag Harbor
- Price
- See ticket page
Editor's Pick Community Crit Night at Studio Kash with Syd Glasser
Syd Glasser hosts a free critique night for Long Island artists who work solo and want feedback in a low-pressure setting. Bring work in progress to Kasher Gallery in Northport—it's a chance to talk through what you're making with other people who actually get it.
- When
- Where
- Kasher Gallery & Studios, Northport
Editor's Pick Kasher Gallery & Studios Anniversary Celebration
Studio Kash is marking one year on Scudder Avenue with an open house—free drinks, snacks, and a chance to see the gallery and studio spaces. It's a casual Sunday afternoon thing, good for meeting the people behind the workshops and checking out the spot if you haven't been yet.
- When
- Where
- 19 Scudder Ave, Northport
Read before you go
- town spotlight Sayville Village: A Local's Guide for 2026 Sayville Village — the South Shore walkable downtown that locals refuse to gentrify, with restored 19th-century Main Street, the Sayville Cab Company since 1958, the Sayville Restaurant Group anchors (Casa Luis, Cull House), the Saturday Farmers Market on Foster Avenue, the Fire Island ferry terminal at the harbor, and an annual event calendar that runs from Memorial Weekend Classic Car Show through Holiday Stroll. Walking distance from the LIRR. The slow-paced South Shore village that works.
- town spotlight Northport Village: A Local's Guide for 2026 Northport Village — the North Shore harbor village with restored 19th-century Main Street, the working harbor + town park, the Engeman Theater, the Saturday farmers market, and the John W. Engeman Theatre + Northport Yacht Club rituals that anchor the village's calendar. Walking distance from the LIRR. The North Shore family Saturday at its best.
- town spotlight Babylon Village: A Local's Guide for 2026 The complete local's guide to Babylon Village — the South Shore's underrated harbor village. Argyle Theater, Argyle Lake, the restaurant strip, Fire Island ferry access, and the off-hours moves locals know.